How we review
Where our information comes from, and what the scores mean.
Where the information comes from
We start with the listing: page count, sections, supported devices, included versions and price. When a listing leaves something out, we say so instead of guessing. Vague listings lose points for that reason.
We take prices from each listing on the date in the footer. Most Etsy templates are almost always on sale, so we show both the sale price and the regular price. When a shop prices in another currency, we show the dollar price Etsy displays to US buyers, which moves with the exchange rate.
The four scores
- Layout
- Does the page plan hold up to a year of use? We look for room each day, a weekly view, and space for notes, meetings and goals.
- Navigation
- How many taps it takes to reach any page, and whether the tabs stay clear of the toolbar.
- Screen fit
- Whether the maker designed the file for your screen's shape and resolution or resized it from another device.
- Value
- What you get for the price, including extra years and versions.
The overall score isn't a simple average. Layout and screen fit count more, because you notice them every day.
Reader reviews
Anyone who owns a template can review it on its page: one to five stars, which tablet they use it on, how long they've used it, and a few sentences. We email a link to confirm the address, then read the review before it goes up, usually within a day. We don't edit reviews. We turn down ones that aren't about the template, that carry links or that look like they came from the shop. Makers can reply under a review but can't remove it. Readers can mark a review helpful or report it; three reports take a review down until we've read it again.
How templates are ranked
The default order, "Top rated", blends our score with reader ratings. Both sit on a five-point scale (our score divided by two), and our review counts the same as eight reader reviews. A template nobody has reviewed yet sits where our score puts it. As reviews come in, readers carry more of the weight; with twenty reviews they count for more than we do. The "Our pick" tag is our opinion and doesn't move a template up the list.
"Reader rating" sorts on reader stars alone, with a slight pull toward the site-wide average so that one five-star review doesn't outrank thirty at 4.8. Templates without reviews come last, in our score's order.
What we count
We count page views, which tablets and filters people pick, and clicks on the links to each store, so we know which reviews are read and which send people on to buy. The site sets no cookies and stores nothing in your browser for this. A visitor is a one-way hash of the connection and browser that changes every day, so we can't follow anyone from one day to the next. Store links pass through this site first (/go/…) to count the click, then go straight to the listing.
Creator submissions
Any template maker can send us a template. We check the link, list it as a submission on the page for each tablet it fits, and may choose it for a full review. No one can pay for a review or a better score.
Links
Store links are plain links. If that changes, for example through an affiliate program, we'll say so here and next to each link.
Sponsor
The site is sponsored by Talisim, which sells travel eSIMs. The sponsor has no say in which templates we review or how we score them.